Blog · 21 October 2026

Magnetic vs Retractable vs Roller Fly Screens: Which Fits?

For most South African windows, especially ones with burglar bars, a rigid magnetic fly screen made to measure is the most practical choice: nothing to install, it fits over the bars and it lifts off to wash. Retractable and roller screens suit people who want the mesh out of sight when it is not needed.

We have made magnetic insect screens in Centurion since 1998, and we do not make retractable or roller screens, so read this with that in mind. We have tried to be fair to all three.

What is the difference between magnetic, retractable and roller fly screens?

A magnetic fly screen is a fixed panel of insect mesh held to the window frame by magnets and lifted off by hand. Retractable and roller screens wind the mesh away into a housing when you do not need it, and pull it across the opening when you do.

A pleated mosquito net works on the same idea as a retractable screen, except the mesh folds up like a concertina instead of rolling.

Magnetic screens also come in two kinds. Some are a soft, foldable mesh with no rigid frame. Ours is a rigid aluminium frame with mesh, held on by 6 to 10 permanent magnets with an average pull-off strength of 4 to 7.5 kg, on a screen that weighs about 1 kg. That is why it stays firmly on the frame but still comes off by hand. You can read more on how magnetic fly screens work.

What are the pros and cons of retractable and roller mosquito nets?

The real advantage of a retractable or roller mosquito net is that the mesh disappears when you roll it away, and it stays on the window, so there is nothing to lift off and put down. On an opening you use all day, that convenience counts.

The trade-offs, from what we have seen of roller and blind-type screens over the years:

  • The mechanical parts wear out over time, so the lifespan is shorter than a fixed screen's.
  • Installation is difficult and expensive.
  • They are not easily compatible with burglar bars.
  • Wind can blow the screen out of its channel.

If you have no bars, you are happy to have a screen fitted, and you mainly want the mesh hidden when it is rolled up, a retractable or roller screen can be a good choice.

How do magnetic screens compare with sliding and frameless screens?

Conventional sliding screens need installation, the good aluminium ones are expensive, and they are hard to keep clean. Frameless magnetic screens avoid installation, but the soft mesh is hard to attach securely and usually needs fixtures on the window frame.

With conventional sliding screens, steel versions are prone to rust, the slide mechanisms often cross-lock so they are hard to move, they cannot be moved to another window, and they may damage aluminium or wooden window frames.

Frameless magnetic screens are also not easily compatible with burglar bars, tend to have a shorter lifespan and are not cost-effective in the long run.

A rigid frame avoids most of this. Ours is powder-coated aluminium in five finishes, so it does not rust, and nothing is fixed to the window. The one exception is the mill finish (raw aluminium), which can corrode after 10 years or more in coastal areas, so on the coast choose a colour.

Why choose a magnetic fly screen?

A rigid magnetic screen has no moving parts to wear out and needs no installation. It is made to measure for one window, delivered to you, and you place it on the frame yourself. It fits over burglar bars and handles, comes off to wash, and moves with you when you change house.

  • Burglar bars and handles: the screen is 35 mm deep inside, so it sits over bars, handles and fittings even with the window closed, and a woolpile seal closes the gap around the bars.
  • Any frame: magnets hold to steel frames on their own. For aluminium, wooden and PVC frames we supply small pre-glued, colour-matched Chromadek steel plates, so nothing is screwed in and the frame is not damaged.
  • Easy to clean: lift it off and hose it down. The mesh catches a lot of dust, so being able to wash it, and the window behind it, matters.
  • Light and view: the fibreglass mesh lets through 69% of the light and its openings, about 1.5 x 1.4 mm, are fine enough for mosquitoes and flies.
  • Yours to keep: a screen moves to any other window of the same size, and you can replace damaged mesh yourself.

See our mosquito nets for windows for sizes and finishes.

When is a magnetic screen not the best fit?

A magnetic panel is not ideal on a door you walk through all day. Our door panels have no hinges, so you take the panel off and put it back each time, which can become a nuisance. For a busy door, a security gate panel or a sliding door panel is usually better.

For sliding doors and sliding windows we make a non-magnetic panel that fits into the existing U-channels, with no extra track needed. See sliding door fly screens and fly screens for doors for the options.

A few other things to know: louvre windows need an extra extension fitted first, as they do for any make of screen, and if you have blinds you need a gap of at least 38 mm between the window frame and the blinds.

And if what you really want is mesh that vanishes when you do not need it, a retractable screen may suit you better. We would rather you buy the right screen than ours.

To see what magnetic screens would cost for your windows, put your sizes into our price estimator.

By Magniscreen, makers of magnetic insect screens in Centurion since 1998.

See your price in 2 minutes

Enter your window and door sizes and get an instant estimate from our current price list, shipment cost included. No obligation.

Get a price